Welcome To CT

My Left Nutmeg

A community-driven blog featuring news and commentary on local, state, and national politics.

helphaiti

Donate to CT Dems
Enable ActBlue
for CT Races
$
John Larson
(1st CD)
$
Joe Courtney
(2nd CD)
$
Rosa DeLauro
(3rd CD)
$
Jim Himes
(4th CD)
$
Chris Murphy
(5th CD)
$
Ads on My Left Nutmeg
 
 


 
Contact Info
To contact the site admin email ctblogger at ctblogger@yahoo.com

My Left Nutmeg

You Won't Believe This: Chris Shays is Criticizing Blumenthal Over Vietnam!!

by: thomashooker

Tue May 18, 2010 at 15:55:28 PM EDT


( - promoted by ctblogger)

Chicken Hawk Chris Shays has actually dared to criticize Dick Blumenthal about his comments on his military service.  Incredibly, New York Times reporter David Halbfinger has written an article titled "Ex-Congressman Saw Blumenthal's Claims Evolve" in which Shays suggests that he:

"watched with worry as Mr. Blumenthal gradually embellished his military record over the years."

It's incredible that Halbfinger uses Shays as a source regarding Mr. Blumenthal's military record in light of the fact that Mr. Shays has been lying about his military record for many years.  Shays has repeatedly over many years responded when questioned as to why he didn't serve in the military that, "I didn't enter the military; I served in the Peace Corps." Though he doesn't actually insert the word "instead", he certainly implies it.  The problem is that Peace Corps service was never considered as the basis for granting a deferment or an exemption by the Selective Service Administration.

I, too, served in the Peace Corps from 1978 to 1981, and I recall Peace Corps officials telling us that the Peace Corps did not exempt anyone from the draft, and that, indeed, PCV's were regularly pulled out of their overseas sites and inducted into the military.  And when Mr. Shays repeatedly used the excuse of Peace Corps service, I wrote to the Selective Service Administration directly and received back written confirmation that Peace Corps service was not considered the basis for a deferment or exemption from the draft.

Shays received the extremely low lottery number of 5 in December 1969, which should have insured that he was drafted.  But he wasn't.  And as recently as two months ago, Shays told Nick Keppler, editor of Fairfield County Weekly, that he wasn't drafted in 1969 because he was serving in the Peace Corps in Fiji.

Chris Shays then filed for and was granted conscientious objector status in 1972, but wasn't required to perform any alternative service whatsoever, an unusual out for a CO.  But again, no one in the Connecticut press corps has ever asked Mr. Shays to explain how he got out of military service, or about the morality of claiming CO status, but supporting enthusiastically the war in Iraq.

So it's absolutely hypocritical and shocking that Chris Shays would dare to comment on Mr. Blumenthal's military record when Blumenthal actually did serve in the military and Shays first avoided the draft in some way that he won't disclose, and then claimed that he was morally against all wars as a CO.  And it's incredible that anyone in the media would take Chris Shays seriously about anyone's military service.

Perhaps it's finally time that the media started to ask Chris Shays some pointed questions about his own draft record, and stopped accepting his lies.

It's time.

thomashooker :: You Won't Believe This: Chris Shays is Criticizing Blumenthal Over Vietnam!!
Tags: , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email

Have you emailed or called Halbfinger to share your research with him? (0.00 / 0)
His email is halbfi@nytimes.com. If you call the main line of the NY Times (212-556-1234), you can get a reporter directory that will connect you to his extension.

I did email him. (0.00 / 0)
First he responded: "he's a conscientious objector."  Then I pointed out that his CO application came three years after he somehow got out of the draft.  Then Halbfinger wrote back, cryptically, "thanks for that".  

So my guess is that he doesn't care.  But you never know.


[ Parent ]
maybe you should have mentioned (0.00 / 0)
... that Shays is a pathological liar ... and a Republican. (Is that redundant?).

In other words, he might have gotten a more objective opinion from someone like the leader of the Marine Corps organizations Blumenthal has spoken to.


[ Parent ]
Good point. But... (0.00 / 0)
doing that would have ruined a perfectly good hatchet-job then, wouldn't it!

[ Parent ]
They've updated the story (0.00 / 0)
It now says "Shays, a conscientious objector who avoided the Vietnam War..."

Still not entirely accurate, but an improvement over no mention.


Only a little improvement..very little. (0.00 / 0)
The reporter still won't admit that Shays is a liar and hypocrite who has misled voters about his own past with Vietnam.  It's pretty dishonest of New York Times.

I didn't think the guy would be honest and ruin his hit-piece, and he didn't.


[ Parent ]
I added this comment to the online article. Wonder if it will be published...doubtful? (0.00 / 0)
Chris Shays was a conservative Republican and in no way a "colleague" of Dick Blumenthal. And Chris Shays has his own falsehoods regarding his military history that he refuses to admit, and that the media in Connecticut never probed. Chris Shays only claimed conscientious objector status in 1972. Yet in 1969 at the height of the Vietnam War his draft lottery number of 5 came up, which should have meant that he was drafted immediately. But somehow Shays managed to avoid the draft. Shays stated that he wasn't drafted because he was serving in the Peace Corps in Fiji. Indeed, Shays has repeatedly over many years stated that he served in the Peace Corps instead of entering the military. But Peace Corps service was never accepted by the Selective Service Administration as grounds for a draft deferral or an exemption. Yet the press has never called Shays out on his deliberate deception. This article, too, fails to point out the fact that Mr. Shays' deceptions regarding his draft record are far more egregious than Mr. Blumenthal's statements. And to use Chris Shays as a commentator on Mr. Blumenthal's problematic statements without revealing that Shays himself has blatantly dissembled regarding his own military record is highly unethical.

This story should be pulled.


[ Parent ]
"Journalists" muck it up (0.00 / 0)
Great piece in the CT Mirror about the lousy job of journalism surrounding this story.

Not only did journalists routinely quote Blumenthal discussing his Vietnam service without ever fact-checking, they went as far as to perpetuate a myth that Blumenthal served IN Vietnam -- despite conflicting statements by Blumenthal himself. Sloppy, sloppy.

Things have gone terribly awry when the subject of the reporting blames journalists not for posting stories that are false but for perpetuating a fiction of his own making, whether unintentionally created or not. ...

The news organization that broke the story, the New York Times, appeared to be seeking to boost its stock price by outsourcing investigative reporting to political campaign operatives. [...]

The New York Times responded to criticism about its exclusive by stating that it pursued independent reporting for the story. Yet it strains belief that The Blumenthal Misstatement had its origins in anything but a methodical attempt by a campaign organization to push a news organization toward pursuing a story damaging to a political rival. ...

There's nothing new with reporters fielding tips from political parties. It happens all the time, but for the most part, the tips are treated for what they are: propaganda and subsequently dismissed. What's troubling about The Blumenthal Misstatement isn't that the New York Times published information that clearly emerged first in opposition research. It's the implication that in this period of constrained news resources, future investigative reporting will depend on the kindness of the strange people who work in the shadows of politics, the kind of people who were once the target of the very journalistic practices they now promote.



 
0 user(s) logged on.
Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


Spotlight

Use the Spotlight tool to send a diary to offline journalists, with your feedback or suggestions.
(What is Spotlight?)


Search


   Advanced
My Left Nutmeg Feeds

Links


Connecticut's War Dead

Blogroll
Powered By
- SoapBlox

Connecticut Blogs
- Capitol Watch
- Colin McEnroe
- Connecticut2.com
- Connecticut Bob
- ConnecticutBlog
- CT Blue Blog
- CT Energy Blog
- CT Local Politics
- CT News Junkie
- CT Smart Growth
- CT Voices for Civil Justice
- CT Voters Count
- CT Weblogs
- CT Working Families Party
- CT Young Dems
- Cool Justice Report
- Democracy for CT
- Drinking Liberally (New Milford)
- East Haven Politics
- Emboldened
- Hat City Blog (Danbury)
- The Laurel
- Jon Kantrowitz
- LieberWatch
- NB Politicus (New Britain)
- New Haven Independent
- Nutmeg Grater
- Only In Bridgeport
- Political Capitol (Brian Lockhart)
- A Public Defender
- Rep. David McCluskey
- Rep. Tim O'Brien
- State Sen. Gary Lebeau
- Saramerica
- Stamford Talk
- Spazeboy
- The 40 Year Plan
- The Trough (Ted Mann: New London Day)
- Undercurrents (Hartford IMC)
- Wesleying
- Yale Democrats

CT Sites
- Clean Up CT
- CT Citizen Action Group
- CT Democratic Party
- CT For Lieberman Party
- CT General Assembly
- CT Secretary of State
- CT-N (Connecticut Network)
- Healthcare4every1.org
- Judith Blei Government Relations
- Love Makes A Family CT

CT Candidates
- Chris Murphy for Senate
- Susan Bysiewicz for Senate

- William Tong for Senate


Other State Blogs
- Alabama
- Arizona
- California
- Colorado
- Delaware
- Florida
- Georgia
- Idaho
- Illinois
- Indiana
- Iowa
- Kentucky
- Louisiana
- Maine
- Maryland
- Massachusetts
- Michigan
- Minnesota
- Missouri
- Missouri
- Montana
- Nebraska
- Nevada
- New Hampshire
- New Jersey
- New Mexico
- New York
- New York
- North Carolina
- Ohio
- Ohio
- Oklahoma
- Oregon
- Pennsylvania
- Rhode Island
- South Dakota
- Tennessee
- Texas
- Texas
- Utah
- Vermont
- Virginia
- Washington
- West Virginia
- Wisconsin



More blogs about connecticut+politics.
Technorati Blog Finder


 
Powered By
MLN is powered by SoapBlox
 
Powered by: SoapBlox